6 Common Misconceptions About Hoarding


Hoarding disorder is a complex condition that affects many people around the world. It often goes undiagnosed, and many misconceptions about the disorder exist in popular culture. In this article, we will explore the definition of hoarding and common misconceptions surrounding the disorder.

Defining hoarding and common misconceptions

Hoarding disorder is a mental health condition that involves excessive acquisition and difficulty discarding possessions. People with hoarding disorder often have cluttered living spaces that may interfere with normal daily activities, causing distress or impairing functioning.

One of the most common misconceptions about hoarding is that it is a choice or a lifestyle preference. However, hoarding disorder is not a choice, and people with the condition often experience feelings of shame, guilt, and isolation as a result of their behavior. It is also not simply a matter of being messy or disorganized, as many people with hoarding disorder actually have difficulty with decision-making and organizing their belongings.

Another misconception is that hoarding only affects older adults or individuals who have experienced trauma. While these groups may be more susceptible to the condition, hoarding disorder can affect anyone regardless of age, gender, race, or socioeconomic status.

Finally, hoarding disorder is often mistaken for other conditions such as OCD or depression. While there may be overlapping symptoms, hoarding disorder is a distinct condition that requires its own treatment approach.

Overall, it is important to recognize that hoarding disorder is a real and serious mental health condition that requires understanding and empathy from others. By increasing awareness and challenging common misconceptions, we can work towards providing better support and resources for those affected by hoarding disorder.

Misconception 1: Hoarding is just messiness

Hoarding vs messiness

Hoarding disorder is often mistakenly associated with being messy or disorganized. However, there is a significant difference between hoarding and messiness. While messy individuals may have cluttered spaces, they are still able to discard unwanted items and clean their environment when necessary. In contrast, individuals with hoarding disorder find it challenging to get rid of anything, even if it holds no value or poses a safety hazard.

The difference between collecting and hoarding

Another common misconception about hoarding is that it is simply an excessive form of collecting. However, collecting involves a certain level of organization and enjoyment, whereas hoarding leads to compulsive behavior and dysfunction in daily activities. People who collect also typically display their items or share them with others, whereas those with hoarding disorder may keep their possessions hidden and resist any attempts to declutter their home. It is important to recognize that hoarding is a distinct condition that requires professional support and intervention.

Misconception 2: Hoarders are lazy

The mental and emotional tolls of hoarding

It is easy for people to label individuals with hoarding disorder as lazy or unmotivated, but the reality is that hoarding can have severe mental and emotional impacts on a person. Many individuals who hoard struggle with anxiety, depression, and shame, leading them to engage in compulsive behaviors as a way to cope. This can lead to a vicious cycle of accumulating more items to mask these underlying issues.

The role of hoarding in coping mechanisms

Hoarding can also serve as a way for individuals to cope with past traumas or loss. They may hold onto possessions as a way to feel a sense of control or comfort in their lives. However, this coping mechanism can quickly spiral out of control and lead to significant interference in daily functioning. It is essential to approach hoarding disorder with empathy and understanding rather than judgment or criticism. Seeking professional support and intervention can help individuals with hoarding disorder manage their symptoms and overcome the challenges they face.

Misconception 3: Hoarding is a lifestyle choice

The influence of genetics and environment on hoarding

People often assume that hoarding is a conscious decision, but that’s far from the truth. Both genetic and environmental factors play a significant role in the development of hoarding disorder. Studies have found that individuals with a family history of hoarding are more likely to develop the disorder themselves. Meanwhile, traumatic experiences or living in impoverished or chaotic environments can trigger hoarding behavior.

The impact of trauma on hoarding tendencies

For many individuals, hoarding disorder stems from a history of trauma or loss. Holding onto items can provide a sense of comfort and stability amidst difficult times, but this coping mechanism can escalate into compulsive hoarding that interferes with day-to-day life. Understanding the emotional and psychological reasons behind hoarding can allow for a more compassionate approach towards individuals with the disorder. Seeking professional support and therapy can help individuals address the root causes of their hoarding behavior and develop healthier coping mechanisms.

Misconception 4: Hoarding only affects the elderly

Hoarding in different age groups

Contrary to popular belief, hoarding disorder can occur in individuals of all ages, from children to the elderly. While it’s true that the prevalence of hoarding tends to increase with age, it is not exclusive to the elderly. In fact, research has shown that hoarding behaviors can manifest in childhood or adolescence and continue into adulthood if left unchecked.

The prevalence of hoarding behaviors in society

Hoarding disorder affects an estimated 2-5% of the population, which translates to millions of people around the world. This disorder can interfere with daily functioning, relationships, and present a serious danger to a person’s physical and emotional health. Due to societal stigmatization and shame surrounding hoarding, many individuals may never seek professional help or disclose their struggles with loved ones. It’s important to educate ourselves on the reality of hoarding disorder and approach those who are struggling with compassion and understanding.

Misconception 5: Hoarding doesn’t harm anyone

The effects of hoarding on loved ones and community members

Contrary to popular belief, hoarding often has far-reaching consequences beyond the individual struggling with the disorder. Hoarding can put a strain on relationships with loved ones and make it difficult for family and friends to visit the home. The accumulation of objects can also pose a fire or sanitation hazard that affects not only the individual but the entire community. Additionally, hoarding can lead to isolation and social withdrawal, further damaging relationships and mental health.

The risks of hoarding behavior

Hoarding presents serious physical and emotional risks to individuals who struggle with the disorder. The accumulation of objects can obstruct walkways, posing a tripping or falling risk. Objects can also topple over, causing injury or damage. Living in cluttered and unsanitary conditions can lead to health problems such as respiratory issues from mold or insect infestations. The emotional toll of hoarding can also lead to depression, anxiety, and self-isolation. It’s crucial to seek professional help if you or someone you love is struggling with hoarding disorder.

Misconception 6: Hoarding can be easily cured

The challenges of treating hoarding disorders

It’s a common misconception that hoarding is a behavior that can be easily cured through simple solutions such as throwing away objects or tidying up. However, hoarding disorder is a complex mental health issue that requires professional treatment. Hoarding behavior is often a result of underlying psychological and emotional struggles that need to be addressed in therapy. Additionally, those struggling with hoarding behavior may experience anxiety and distress when faced with letting go of their possessions, making the process of decluttering a daunting and challenging task.

Coping mechanisms and recovery options

The first step in treating hoarding disorder is acknowledging the severity of the problem and seeking professional help. Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) has been shown to be an effective treatment for hoarding disorder, as it focuses on changing negative thought patterns and behaviors. Additionally, family therapy can help loved ones understand the disorder and provide support for recovery. Coping mechanisms such as mindfulness, relaxation techniques, and self-care can also aid in managing symptoms of hoarding disorder. Recovery is a personal journey, but with the right resources and support, it’s possible to overcome hoarding behavior.


Revisiting common misconceptions and the truth behind hoarding

It’s crucial to understand that hoarding disorder is not just a simple behavior that can be easily cured by getting rid of a few items. It’s a complex mental health issue that requires professional treatment, as hoarding behavior is often a result of underlying psychological and emotional struggles. It’s essential to address the root cause of the behavior through therapy and support.

How to support loved ones struggling with hoarding

For those struggling with hoarding disorder, recovery is a personal journey, but with the right resources, it’s possible to overcome this behavior. As family or friends, it’s crucial to provide support and understanding while also encouraging professional help. Educating oneself on hoarding disorder and its complexities can help loved ones understand the challenges of recovery and provide encouragement throughout the process. Coping mechanisms such as mindfulness and relaxation techniques can also be useful tools for managing hoarding behavior.

(For more information, check out this article on the 5 Levels of Hoarding.)

Martijn van Lith offers professionalethical, and confidential extreme decluttering/cleaning services. Why choose us? Because we understand our clients very well, we go beyond just doing the job- we build relationships with our clients, and we treat your possessions with caution and care. We’ve been featured in the news, as well. Our loyal customers can attest to the quality of our services. Check out their testimonials here.